The Apple Store still has the following factory-refurbished Apple iPod shuffle MP3 players, each at 14% to 20% off and the lowest total price we could find. All get free shipping and a 1-year Apple warranty, the same as new iPods. The restocked refurbs (all are current generation models):

• Apple iPod shuffle 2GB MP3 Player in Silver, Blue, Green, or Purple for $59
• Apple iPod shuffle 1GB MP3 Player in Silver, Blue, Green, or Purple for $39
• see more refurbished iPod deals at The Apple Store